Be your best self.

Broken Engagements: Do You Give Back The Ring?

Broken Engagements: Do You Give Back The Ring?
Carly Jacobs

You may or may not know this about me but I happen to be a qualified jeweller. I can melt metal AND my fingers. Queen of Multi-Tasking. Anyway I digress. The reason that I’m telling you this is because whenever I hear of a broken engagement my first question is always ‘What happened to the ring?‘. It’s always such a big deal at the time, all the fussing and showing it off and then when the engagement or marriage ends it sort of disappears. Into a drawer. The back of the jewellery box. Often forever.

I come from a family with an astoundingly low divorce rate. At last count, out of about ten marriages there’s been only one divorce. We’re total martians. There’s no step-kids in my family at all. It’s very weird. So naturally I’m quite fascinated by marriage break ups, having never seen or experienced one up close in real life. Heaps of my friends have divorced parents and I’m like a toddler asking questions about the sky. ‘Does your mum even talk to your dad? What happens at Christmas? Do you get twice as many presents for your birthdays now? Did you have two bedrooms when you were a kid? Did sad music play when your dad moved away?‘. Please don’t think I’m belittling how difficult marriage break ups are. It’s just that I have literally no idea how they happen or what you’re supposed to do when they happen, so I ask questions.

Today’s survey is all about the engagement ring. I’m curious to see what people think about the returning or the keeping of the ring when a relationship ends. Do you keep the ring if you paid for it? Or if your partner cheated on you? If you cheated on him? Is there some kind of protocol in these situations? I’m genuinely curious what people think about this.

As usual, I’ll collate the answers and present them in a fancy graph. Mathematics. I’m doing it.

Please feel free to share in the comments if your story is too complicated for the survey. I’d love to hear any ring returning/keeping stories from real life people!

30 Comments

  1. Jo 11 years ago

    I have no basis for this, but I think if you break up before the wedding, and didn’t pay anything for the ring, then you give it back. After the wedding, it’s probably yours to do with what you want.

    When I got engaged, our money was already all in together, so we both paid for it. If we ever split up (which we will not!) I wouldn’t give it back to him and I don’t think he’d want it.

    I think there used to be society etiquette about giving back the ring if you break an engagement, which I can kind of understand if you’ve put your life savings into it. Very wisely we did not put our life savings into it, and it would not currently be worth enough to fight over!

    Friends who have divorced have kept the rings and sold them or, like Princess Diana, passed them onto the kids!

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      That’s what I thought. I have no friends who have broken engagements just one divorced friend and she kept the ring because it was sort of a birthday present at the time.

  2. Sue GP 11 years ago

    Traditionally if the wedding is called of by the woman she is supposed to return the ring. If the Man calls it off she is able to keep the ring.

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Thanks for that! By traditionally do mean in Australian culture? Or general Western culture? Just curious!

  3. Jasmine 11 years ago

    I’ve mentioned previously that my fiance disappeared without so much as a by your leave, so I got to keep the ring. I often think of pawning it but as my son never got to meet his father I feel like he should at least be able to one day see the ring and know that at some point there was love there. Though now that you’ve mentioned melting it down I’m thinking perhaps that’s something I should think about instead! Turning it into something more beautiful and relevant.

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Oh that’s lovely! If that was me, I think I’d pawn it and buy something beautiful instead. Bad juju with that diamond… and as a jeweller I know diamonds absorb stuff. Start fresh. Your son has a beautiful mum… that’s all he needs. xxx

  4. Tara 11 years ago

    I’m happily married for 10 years but had a super short engagement for various reasons. I’m not emotionally attached to my engagement ring, which I never wear, in the same way as I am to my wedding ring, which I never take off. I’m planning to have the engagement ring melted down and made into a ring for a different finger. Any desire to take on a custom commission?!

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      That’s very sweet but I’m a very average gem setter. It’s a fine art and one that I’m not great at! 🙂 But you’re Canberra right? You’re MY Tara right? Handbag maker? (sorry for not knowing – your name is different on different social media and I get a touch confused!) Go to Bijoux in Manuka. George is a genius. Used to work for him and I wouldn’t trust anyone else.

      • Tara 11 years ago

        Ha ha! Yes, I’m ‘your’ Tara! Thanks for the tip – part of the delay has been having no idea who to take it to!

        • tuffhr 11 years ago

          Yes – definitely go see George! Cannot recommend him highly enough. He remodelled my rings for me 🙂
          Erika

      • Tara 11 years ago

        Ha ha! Yes, I’m ‘your’ Tara! Thanks for the tip – part of the delay has been having no idea who to take it to!

  5. Amber-Rose Thomas 11 years ago

    My understanding was always that the engagement ring was a promise and a form of insurance for the bride, so that if the groom had to call off the engagement – she got to keep it to make up for it so to speak. Therefore after the wedding the ring becomes her property. So, romantic huh?

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Totes romantic. 🙂 Even though I’m not at all in to marriage I’m totally wanting a piece of beautiful jewellery Mr Smaggle to wear every day. I think I deserve that. 🙂

  6. Joanna 11 years ago

    I have had a broken engagement. He broke up with me… or rather, I should say, he dumped me via instant messenger after a year long engagement. So of course I kept the goddamn ring. But it has just sat in the back of the cupboard for 10 years now. I hang on to it mostly because I am a minor hoarder.

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Holy shit. That’s intense. Get it remade into something delicious! Do it! Take real ownership of it. x

  7. Cilosophy.blogspot.com 11 years ago

    I got divorced.
    I instigated it.
    He wanted me to keep the ring.
    I am considering what to do with it- the marriage was an important part of my history which I will incorporate into a happier future.
    It would be poetic if the ring was made into something different too

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      You should totally do that! Where do you live love? Are you Melbourne based?

  8. JessB 11 years ago

    Hmm, this is such a tricky area, and not something I’ve thought about before – which is odd, because my parents split up a couple of years ago, and I’ve been through working out who younger siblings are going to live with, and who gets the baby photos and where we go for Christmas, but I never considered the wedding and engagement rings.

    I know that my Dad still has his, but doesn’t wear it. I can’t recall my Mum wearing her rings, but I’ve never asked her about it or spoken about it with anyone else.

    Personally, it would depend on whether I felt the ring was mine, or whether I felt it was still my fiancee’s – for instance, if we broke up before the wedding, and he had paid for the ring or it was a family heirloom of his, then I would return it. If it was decades after the wedding, I would feel like it was mine, and I would probably keep it, or perhaps give it to my child/ children, maybe make it into something else for them.

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      It’s such an odd little situation. This is why I asked! I’m genuinely so curious.

  9. Dani 11 years ago

    My partner has an ex fiancé and she gave the ring back to him. He had discussions with his mother about what he should do with it, as it was/is a lovely ring that he put a lot of thought and effort into.
    The suggestion was that he might have a daughter one day who would like it. My thought was that the mother of his daughter might not be ok with her daughter wearing a ring that her father have to someone else with plans of spending his life with her…
    He does have plenty of nieces that may appreciate it though!

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Wow. I actually never thought of what happens to the ring when the guy gets it back… re-sell? Re-design? I’m totally Facebooking this.

  10. tuffhr 11 years ago

    Hmm, started doing the survey, then gave up. Because my first engagement (light years ago) never had a ring, and the second one (yep, the keeper), both my rings come from my side of the family. My (divorced) mother said it meant I’d never be under pressure to return them, they would always be mine. Which I totally get, as she was gifted the money for the stone on her engagement ring by her godfather. It’s now my engagement ring. Wedding band is made of stones from my paternal grandmother’s wedding rings. So they are important to me on a LOT of levels.
    Erika

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Whoa that sounds so complicated. It was difficult to articulate the questions to suit most situations! Thank you so much for sharing. x

  11. Michelle. 11 years ago

    My ex-husband and I agreed that I would keep my engagement and wedding rings (they were custom-made for me). I’ve since had the stones from each combined into a dress ring….they were too beautiful to hide away and I would never wear the rings in the format that they were in (all with ex-husbands blessing….our parting was rather amicable)

    • Author
      Smaggle 11 years ago

      Love that! Never waste a diamond!

  12. Nicole 11 years ago

    My aunt recently divorced her husband and she had all of the rings he gave her (they were together for over 20 years) melted down and combined into one mega ring. He is a total dick but those rings were gorgeous. She now has this great looking mix of gems and gold on her right ring finger.

  13. tori amri 10 years ago

    I just wanted to express my gratitude and appreciation to prophet salifu on bringing my fiancee back to me,I was in a relationship for 9 years with my fiancee and all of a sudden, he started seeing another.he started hailing at me and he was abusive.. and he stop careing for me, but I still loved him with all my heart .the situation made me unsettle and not to focus at work .so someone told me about trying spiritual means to get my fiancee back and introduced me to a spell caster? i did not listen to her . i kept on hoping that my fiancee will come back home and beg as he use to . after a month it got out of hand and my fiancee came back home to break the news to me that he is getting married to the other lady .Hmmm i was so shocking to me ,i felt sad and depressed ,so i contacted my friend again and decieded to try to use spiritual means reluctantly..although I didn’t believe in all those things? I never thought in a million years that i will get my fiancee back to me a again. but I was proved wrong.after 2days, my fiancee came back to me and was pleading..he had realized his mistakes..i just couldn’t believe it that we are back together. Prophet salifu remained consistent and kind throughout and made the process unbelievable I am deeply satisfied and thankful .if in doubt you should email him at prophetsalifu@yahoo.com or prophetsalifu@gmail.com

    • Author
      Smaggle 10 years ago

      Spam—
      Sent from Mailbox for iPhone

  14. marrriz 8 years ago

    my boyfriend propose to me, and we’re engaged for almost a year. but then, i was shocked to know the truth that he is already married! what will i do with the ring???

  15. Kimberli Weston 8 years ago

    I’m in this situation RIGHT NOW. ? He’s insisting on having it back, however we both have almost the same amount of money invested in the ring, he spent $2000 on it and I spent $1500 on “tailoring” it, I just had to fire him Friday because he wasn’t doing the job I hired him to do ? And he FLIPPED out and damaged things in my home and left. So I say go ahead and sue me, I’ll counter sue your dumb ass for property damages! Ugh! In the futer I plan to date men who don’t need a job from me. ?

Leave a Reply